Tag Archives: detective

The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey

Standard

When I got this recommendation by Amazon, a number of things appealed to me about the book and so I downloaded it. First, I’ve always been what’s known as a Ricardian. Second, in an early part of my career as a lawyer, I did some criminal work and have experience in breaking down elements of a crime. Third, my ancestors came from England and Scotland and I’ve always had a fascination with the history of the countries. As examples, I have Sir John and Sir Thomas Gresham in my line as well as I’m a MacDonald from Scotland. All this to say, the book is totally in the ambit of works that would attract me.

Josephine Tey wrote this book in 1951, but it still resonates today. The meticulous work by the detective laid up in the hospital with a broken leg seems to me to be on point with his conclusions. Inspector Alan Grant is a wonderful character who, in his experience on the force, has become sort of a self-styled expert on reading faces. He can usually tell (or so he tells himself) if someone is a criminal or an honest person by their face alone.

The side characters are well-drawn and I enjoyed them, especially Grant’s actress friend and his research assistant. His two nurses are both delightfully different from each other.

Bored with being laid up in the hospital and not drawn to the books his friends have dropped off for him, his actress friend decides to bring him some photos to amuse him. He lands on one of Richard III and says he appears to him to be a person to put in a judge category. When he’s told it’s Richard III, he can scarce believe it. Grant is sure the man couldn’t be a criminal based on his face. Grant can’t leave it alone and asks one of his nurses for a history book.

The adventure is on from that point. Grant becomes obsessed with figuring out exactly who killed the princes in the tower. What follows is a well thought out, meticulously researched, investigation into the very crime Richard has stood accused of for centuries.

I very much enjoyed this book. As a Ricardian since I began to read history, I was happy with the research Grant and his able American assistant did as well as the train of thought that led him to his conclusion. Yes, it’s fiction, but man, what a great job he did in his assessment (or should I say Josephine Tey did?).

One thing that I had to look up for myself was why the book was called Daughter of Time as there was no daughter. Interestingly, the name comes from a quote by Sir Francis Bacon about truth being revealed over time. History is written by the victors and in my humble opinion, as well as many others’, Henry Tudor was a usurper and had a very tenuous right to be king, so he had to slander Richard to quell any potential uprisings.

According to Bacon, true knowledge comes from evidence and research over time, rather than just believing what authority figures say. Looking at the historical records of how loyal Richard was to his brother, how he forgave those who betrayed him over the years of his life and spared their lives when it may not have been in his best interests, as well as his fair way of ruling and trying to unite the various factions of the red and white roses, this book makes sense to me.

To the Tudor loyalists, read this novel and see what you think. To my fellow Ricardians, read this novel, you’ll enjoy it like I did.

BLURB:

Inspector Alan Grant of Scotland Yard, recuperating from a broken leg, becomes fascinated with a contemporary portrait of Richard III that bears no resemblance to the Wicked Uncle of history. Could such a sensitive, noble face actually belong to one of the world’s most heinous villains – a venomous hunchback who may have killed his brother’s children to make his crown secure? Or could Richard have been the victim, turned into a monster by the usurpers of England’s throne? Grant determines to find out once and for all, with the help of the British Museum and an American scholar, what kind of man Richard Plantagenet really was and who killed the Little Princes in the Tower.

A Rip in Time by Kelley Armstrong, a Review

Standard

I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an unbiased review.

I really liked this story. I’ve read some of Ms. Armstrong’s work in the past and her prose is always easy to read and enjoyable. The premise here of a modern day female detective transported through time when she’s attacked in a dark lane in old Edinburgh is creative and right up this reader’s alley. Being a huge fan of Edinburgh and having experienced the magic of the city firsthand, in this reader’s opinion, it’s the perfect setting for the story. A very atmospheric town and extra creepy in 1869 when the lighting would have been candles or gas lights.

The heroine is plucky and savvy and learns quickly that she’ll have to work hard to try to fit in where most everything is unfamiliar. The work she has to do as a housemaid is tough yet she realizes a roof over her head in those hard times is worth the backbreaking chores. Even the cleaning of the chamber pots.

Ms. Armstrong does a great job evoking the era in housing and the sights/smells of an old city as well as the biases against women and people of mixed race.

The supporting characters are well-drawn and appealing with each having unique qualities. I especially enjoyed the brother and sister and how they interacted with the heroine as well as each other and the local police detective. There were parts that strained credulity, but being as it’s a time travel story, realism was always going to take a back seat.

The heroine was flawed and made mistakes which made the tale more exciting. A perfect heroine is always dull. The person whose body the heroine was transported into was a wicked person and I’m glad the heroine made many attempts to try to make things right with the people the real housemaid harmed.

It appears there will be more stories with these characters which is great as they each have their own unique back story and I, for one, look forward to exploring more of old Edinburgh with them and learning more about their lives.